Journal of Evolutionary Biology

Sperm competition can occur when sperm from two or more males compete for fertilization of a batch of eggs. While it has been extensively studied in internal fertilizers, it remains poorly under-stood in external fertilizers. To investigate how sperm competition affects fertilization under sperm limitation, we conducted controlled experiments on two sea urchin species: Paracentrotus lividus and Dendraster excentricus. Eggs from a single female were exposed to sperm from three individ-ual males separately (non-competitive treatment) or to a pooled sample from three males (competi-tive treatment). We measured fertilization success as proportion of eggs fertilized after two hours and assessed sperm motility as percentage of motile sperm and curvilinear velocity. For P. lividus , we estimated the sperm concentrations where fertilization success was 50% of maximum observed fertilization success (F50), and the fertilization efficiency of the sperm (Fe), i.e. the likelihood that a sperm - egg encounter results in a fertilizing contact, using the fertilization kinetics model of Styan (1998). For D. excentricus, fertilization success was measured at a sperm concentration expected to produce 50% fertilization success. Sperm competition reduced fertilization success and increased F50 compared to non-competitive treatments, suggesting antagonistic effects that may compromise fertilization under sperm-limited conditions in external fertilizers.

Genetic variation exists for many male reproductive traits despite apparent strong sexual selection in favor of particular males. Understanding how that variation is maintained is an unresolved problem in evolutionary biology. One proposed solution to this problem is genotype-by-environment interactions (GEIs), where no male genotype is universally superior across environments. Another proposed answer is variation in female preference, such that different females prefer different male genotypes. Additionally, male genotypes may differ in their reproductive output as they age. The house fly Musca domestica is a well-suited system to evaluate these explanations for genetic variation in male reproductive traits because two male genotypes (YM and IIIM) differ in mating performance. Specifically, IIIM males outcompete YM males in mating assays because IIIM males have a shorter copulation latency. To determine the relative importance of GEIs, female variation, and male age on the maintenance of genetic variation in male reproductive behaviors, we performed non-competitive (one male to one female) and competitive (one IIIM male and one YM male to one female) mating assays while considering multiple ages and different female strains. IIIM males attempted more matings regardless of competition level, female genotype or age, but mated faster than YM males only with females of their own strain and only performed more matings in non-competitive trials. However, female strain did not improve the mating success of YM males. We also did not observe evidence for genotype-by-age interactions on male mating success. Importantly, we did not identify any conditions where YM males outcompeted IIIM males, and therefore there was no evidence for interactions or trade-offs that could explain the maintenance of genetic variation for male mating success. To explain the maintenance of IIIM and YM males, other factors such as additional social environments or varying temperature should be investigated, as the genotypes are found in natural environments with contrasting temperatures.

Transgenerational plasticity (TGP)- when parental environments influence offspring phenotypes - is ubiquitous across taxonomic groups and can have benefits for offspring beyond what is possible with developmental plasticity, particularly when selective pressures are high early in life. However, patterns of TGP vary widely across populations and species, and the evolutionary processes shaping this variation remain poorly understood. Here, we tested whether repeated evolutionary transitions result in parallel or population-specific evolutionary divergence in TGP relative to ancestral conditions. We examined sperm-mediated paternal effects across two ancestral marine and three derived freshwater populations of threespined stickleback fish (Gasterosteus aculeatus). We exposed fathers to dragonfly larvae (endemic to freshwater) or sculpin (endemic to all populations) predators and measured both paternal response to predators as well as antipredator behavior and growth in larval offspring. Fathers behaviorally responded to the presence of sculpin predators, but not dragonfly larvae. However, we found strong paternal effects in response to both predators in all populations. Further, the magnitude of TGP did not differ between marine and freshwater populations, suggesting that TGP does not become genetically accommodated as marine populations move into freshwater habitats. We found some evidence consistent with parallelism in both within and trans-generational plasticity: 1) personal exposure of larval stickleback to dragonfly larvae elicited strong antipredator responses in freshwater populations that were absent in marine populations, and 2) paternal predation exposure consistently increased offspring growth in marine populations while slowing growth in freshwater populations. In contrast, paternal effects altered offspring behavior in population-specific ways, with strong sex-specific effects of paternal exposure emerging in response to endemic predators. Adaptive evolution is a two-step process, in which heritable genotypic and phenotypic variation must first be present and then selected on. Therefore, high population-level variation in TGP suggests the capacity for rapid evolution of parental effects, while signatures of parallelism and sex-specific patterns suggest that TGP may evolve in targeted ways in response to ecological stressors.

Whether sexual selection facilitates or hinders adaptation to novel environments is a question of fundamental importance due to current rapid environmental change. Using phylogenetic comparative analysis in 42 Drosophila species, we found that sperm length - a sexually selected ornament - positively associates with the ability of males to survive high temperatures. However, the ability to remain fertile does not increase with sperm length to the same extent, meaning that longer sperm species experience a larger gap between temperatures that kill and temperatures that sterilize males. The findings are consistent with the idea that strong sexual selection on condition-dependent exaggerated traits may facilitate somatic resilience to environmental stressors, but that susceptibility to heat-induced infertility may be a cost of extreme sperm ornamentation. Overall, the data suggests multifaceted links between postcopulatory sexual selection and climate change.

Reproductive success often depends on coordinated combinations of morphology, dispersal ability, and mating behavior. Supergenes, genomic regions of suppressed recombination, allow such combinations to be inherited by offspring as a single unit. In ants, independently evolved supergenes control colony queen number, yet few studies have investigated their joint influence on morphology, mating, and colony-founding in sexuals. Formica cinerea provides a unique opportunity to address this question because it harbors two supergenes that together produce three queen and male morphs: large monogyne, large polygyne, and small polygyne. Here we show that these supergenes jointly shape an integrated suite of traits across the reproductive cycle. Wing area was primarily associated with the chromosome 3 supergene, with monogyne individuals having larger wings than polygyne individuals. Thorax volume was associated with the chromosome 9 supergene, with small polygyne individuals having reduced thorax volume regardless of social origin. Mating was assortative for both supergenes in large morphs but random in small polygyne queens. Independent colony founding was almost exclusively performed by large monogyne queens; initial egg production was unaffected by mate genotype. These findings show that the two supergenes jointly coordinate dispersal morphology, mate choice, and colony-founding into coherent reproductive strategies, preventing maladaptive intermediate phenotypes.

Parasites decrease host fitness, more so during physiologically challenging life stages such as migration. However, parasites are unevenly distributed among individuals, and hosts with different physiological condition may face different costs of migration with infections. We tested whether the relationship between infection by haemosporidian parasites and oxidative balance during autumn migration in blackcaps depends on individual age and sex, two major sources of variation in prevalence and physiological condition. We captured blackcaps at stopover in central Spain and measured infection status and physiological parameters. Blackcaps physiologically more prepared to depart from stopover had lower antioxidant capacity of plasma, probably because of physiological adjustments prior to the upcoming flight stage. Plasmodium parasites occurred only in coinfections, which were more frequent among young blackcaps. Regardless of individual sex and age, coinfected birds had lower antioxidant capacity of plasma, and blackcaps coinfected with Plasmodium had more oxidative damage to lipids in their red blood cells. Our results support the idea that haemosporidian infections impair the oxidative balance of blackcaps during autumn migration, which could impair individual performance and ultimately fitness, with increased population impacts during the first year of life when a larger proportion of individuals migrate coinfected with harmful Plasmodium parasites.

Copper is an essential micronutrient in most organisms that becomes toxic in large quantities. Repeated or prolonged sub-lethal exposure can lead to evolved resistance to copper toxicity over many generations, which may result in trade-offs between energetically expensive detoxification mechanisms and fitness. Alternatively, evolved resistance to chemical stressors may lead to correlated changes in other traits. This study focuses on a population of flies for which artificial selection for copper resistance led to an increase in both copper resistance and longevity. The apparent off-target benefit of copper selection on one component of fitness led us to investigate differences in fecundity and developmental viability in copper resistant and copper sensitive, non-selected populations. We assessed the effect of copper selection and copper exposure on multiple aspects of fecundity over the lifespans of females from the non-selected and copper-selected populations. Our study corroborated previously observed increased longevity in copper-selected flies. Controlling for variation in lifespan, copper-resistant females had comparable age-matched fecundity to copper-sensitive females and benefitted from increased longevity with higher lifetime fecundity. Overall, copper exposure negatively affected egg quality, but we found no difference in this trait between the copper-resistant and sensitive populations. Further, we found developmental viability under copper stress was significantly higher for eggs laid by copper-resistant females. Overall, we determined that copper resistant flies experienced a fitness benefit through both lifespan and fecundity. Costs of maintaining copper resistance may be associated with energetic costs, but these trade-offs may not always manifest in reproductive or lifespan fitness costs.

Allee effects are positive relationships between components of individual fitness and the number or density of individuals in a population. Negative density effects are well documented in Drosophila melanogaster across life stages, while Allee effects are rare and largely confined to the larval stages. However, despite the costs of high density, adult flies are found to exhibit attraction to same-sex conspecifics, suggesting some fitness value to the presence of conspecifics. We measured fitness related traits of singly mated-females housed at same-sex densities of 1, 2, or 10 and found clear reductions in lifetime reproductive output at low densities. Additionally, these females concentrated reproductive effort within early adulthood, albeit without improving estimates of fitness. When housed at variable densities, females altered their reproductive output in response to immediate densities, but were unable to improve it unless remating was possible, indicating an interaction between mating and density. Overall, our findings suggest that reproductive plasticity in response to the presence of conspecifics mediates positive effects of density on fitness in female Drosophila melanogaster. Understanding the physiological and ecological bases of such plasticity may help explain the evolution of social tendency in the fly.

Vertebrates cope with rapid temperature fluctuations by plastically adjusting their behaviour and physiology. This phenotypic plasticity is partly mediated by plastic changes in glucocorticoid levels; however, whether individual differences in endocrine plasticity are associated with fitness remains unknown. Here, we examined the relationship between individual variation in glucocorticoid plasticity in response to air temperature changes and reproductive success in a wild great tit population (Parus major). Over nine years, we collected repeated measurements of baseline and stress-induced corticosterone during nestling rearing. We found consistent reaction norm patterns in hormone response to temperature variation -- as shown in a previous study conducted over a shorter period. This provides robust evidence of individual differences in average hormone levels (intercepts) and the strength of the plastic response (slopes), indicating potential for evolution. However, neither intercepts nor slopes were associated with reproductive success (fledgling number or brood mass), suggesting that individual variation in endocrine plasticity was not under natural selection, at least within the environmental conditions experienced. This study provides a first empirical test of the evolutionary implications of endocrine plasticity in the wild and highlights the need to assess its fitness relevance under more extreme conditions, such as those expected under future climate scenarios.

Animal behaviour is both innately constrained and shaped by learning. This mosaic organization has evolved in response to species-specific ecological demands and may differ between sensory modalities. Flower-visiting animals are a particularly useful system for investigating the relationship between sensory ecology and learning because they rely on multiple floral cues, particularly odour and colour, to locate food sources. However, it remains largely unexplored whether specialization on floral resources entails divergence in learning abilities across sensory modalities. Drosophila elegans is a flower-feeding species that depends heavily on floral resources throughout its life; adults spend much of their time on flowers and larvae develop on fallen flower leaves. Here, we compared odour-reward and colour-reward associative learning between the flower-feeding D. elegans and the fruit-feeding D. melanogaster. We found that, under conditions of equilibrated motivation, odour- and colour-preference, and using the same sugar reward, D. elegans exhibited poorer odour-reward learning performance but better colour-reward learning performance than D. melanogaster. These results suggest that the modality-specific eligibility of sensory information to enter into associations, known as the 'Garcia-effect' in experimental psychology, can evolve oppositely between species. This highlights the relationship between ecological specialization and mnemonic processing, and shows that biological 'intelligence' is not general.

The toxicity of chemical defences is well studied, but the potential contribution of compound structure to predator deterrence remains largely unexplored. Whether predation acts more strongly on toxicity or unpalatability remains largely untested, partly because few systems allow toxin structure to vary independently of quantity. Heliconius sara larvae provide such a system: those reared on Passiflora auriculata sequester cyclopentenyl cyanogenic glucosides (CGs), while those reared on P. biflora biosynthesise comparable quantities of aliphatic CGs. Using two invertebrate predators, Camponotus floridanus ants and Hierodula membranacea mantids, we tested whether this structural difference affects palatability independent of toxicity. Mantids rejected larvae with cyclopentenyl CGs more often than larvae with aliphatic CGs, despite no detectable difference in total CG content. This pattern was mirrored in extract-based assays with ants, independently of cyanide release: extracts with cyclopentenyl CGs remained deterrent, while extracts with aliphatic CGs did not differ in deterrence from water. Live larvae, by contrast, elicited similar responses from ants regardless of CG structure. These results show that variation in toxin structure can strongly affect palatability, with some compounds conferring greater protection than others. This demonstrates the importance of chemical structural diversity in the evolution of chemical defences.

As one of the strongest selective forces, predation risk induces antipredator responses in prey that not only maximise survival probability but are energetically expensive. While these responses are known to affect foraging patterns and diet composition, the functional role of changes in dietary macronutrients remains unclear. We investigated the effect of dietary NPE (non-protein energy) concentration on the antipredator responses of the Indian rock agama Psammophilus dorsalis. In a manipulative experiment, wild-caught lizards were fed either a low or high NPE diet and exposed to repeated simulated predator attacks. We measured the space-use and hiding duration of lizards after each attack, as well as their circulating corticosterone concentrations at the end of the experiment. Predator exposure induced refuge use for all lizards. Diet had a context-dependent effect: lizards on the high NPE diet used riskier perch locations more frequently than those on low NPE diets, but only during safe periods and not during active threat. Physiologically, lizards on the low NPE diet had significantly higher baseline corticosterone levels, indicating a greater allostatic load. Overall, while dietary NPE did not alter reactive escape behaviour, it influenced the underlying physiological state and proactive behavioural decisions.

Species interactions shape ecological dynamics, but adaptation to one interaction can trade off with others. Experiments that measure such evolved fitness changes across multiple interactions remain rare. We used experimental evolution to test whether recent selection under one ecological interaction changes fitness under other interactions in a fly-parasitoid system. We evolved a genetically diverse Drosophila melanogaster population for 15-17 generations under three regimes: benign conditions (control), high intraspecific competition, and infection by the parasitoid wasp Leptopilina boulardi. We then measured fly fitness (egg-to-adult survival and subsequent reproduction) under benign conditions, high intraspecific competition, and infection by three other parasitoid species and an additional conspecific L. boulardi strain. Selection history strongly influenced fitness across interactions. Populations maintained under high larval density showed reduced survival under infection by L. boulardi and L. victoriae, indicating a trade-off between past selection for competition and defence against some parasitoids. Populations evolved under parasitoid infection by L. boulardi showed increased resistance to a conspecific strain but reduced fitness when infected by another species, L. heterotoma. Our results show that rapid evolution in response to a single interaction can reshape multiple ecological interactions through fitness trade-offs, highlighting how recent evolutionary history may influence community dynamics and invasion susceptibility.

Phenotypic differences among populations can arise through heritable genetic divergence, phenotypic plasticity, or both, making it difficult to determine whether trait-environment correlations observed in nature reflect adaptive evolution. Within threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) studies, numerous document morphological differences among allopatric-, parapatric-, and even sympatric populations. These phenotypic differences among populations are often correlated with diet and lake habitat (e.g., lake size), suggesting an adaptive value to the population differences. However, many studies of ecomorphological divergence in stickleback use wild-caught stickleback, which may differ due to evolution or plasticity. Although common garden experiments have confirmed that population differences can be heritable, such experiments typically entail small numbers of populations. Consequently, we still do not know to what extent well-known trait-environment correlations in stickleback are a result of evolution. To address this gap, we reared stickleback embryos from 27 lake populations on Vancouver Island, in a laboratory environment. Morphological differences among populations persist in common-garden fish, confirming a large role for divergent evolution. These heritable differences were associated with environmental variation among lakes, implying an adaptive value. However, some well-known trait-environment relationships in stickleback did not persist in common-garden fish and may be primarily plastic.

Understanding how divergence in reproductive traits can promote speciation remains a fundamental question in evolutionary biology. Sperm morphology and kinematics diverge rapidly across species. However, the effect of hybridization between recently diverged species on sperm traits remains unclear, limiting our understanding of how reproductive isolation evolves. Here, we evaluated sperm morphology, kinematics, and trait integration in species of a young (~10,000 years), sympatric Cyprinodon pupfish radiation from San Salvador Island, Bahamas, as well as fertile advanced-generation hybrids between two of these species. We found significant divergence in flagellum length, midpiece area, and sperm velocity among species. In contrast, hybrids displayed transgressive kinematic profiles defined by high velocities, reduced path curvature, and distinct patterns of sperm kinematic integration. Our findings suggest that hybridization between recently diverged species may reorganize the underlying control of sperm locomotor mechanisms, generating novel phenotypes that could contribute to reproductive isolation in the early stages of speciation.

Sexual interactions involve the exchange of information-including olfactory, auditory, and visual cues-that has been shaped by sexual selection to maximize fitness. While these courtship signals and behaviors are often characterized as stereotypical and species-specific, male courtship is plastic and can depend on the population identity of the courted female. The ability of a male to adjust his courtship behavior based on female identity has significant implications for how selection operates on courtship, potentially driving behavioral divergence between populations and the eventual emergence of new species. A major challenge is identifying the cues that males use to adjust their courtship strategy. We used Drosophila melanogaster to investigate the mechanisms facilitating courtship plasticity, focusing on male song production. Male song is often considered the paramount behavior performed by males and is stimulated by female pheromones. Previous observations have focused on cosmopolitan (non-African) genotypes, whereas the singing rate and singing plasticity is highly variable in African populations. In genotypes from Zimbabwe, females have a different major pheromone compound (5,9-HD) compared to non-African females and show strong behavioral preference for Zimbabwe males. We created a Zimbabwe genotype lacking 5,9-HD by disrupting the gene desat2 in the Zimbabwe Z53 strain. We tested the hypothesis that Zimbabwe male courtship plasticity depends on female pheromones by allowing males to court non-African, wild type Z53, and Z53 desat2 null mutant females. We found that males treated Z53 desat2 null females like wild type Z53 females, not using pheromone cues to determine singing and courtship plasticity. This suggests that other female behavioral feedback influences singing plasticity. This courtship plasticity could contribute to the asymmetrical reproductive isolation between these populations and could provide insight to the broad pattern of asymmetrical reproductive isolation across broad taxonomic groups.

The evolutionary patterns of trait diversification provide insights into the function of the trait. Early burst of trait evolution is often associated with adaptive radiation, rapidly diversifying the trait in response to vacant niches followed by the slowdown of the diversification with niche filling, whereas late burst is more likely to be associated with sexual selection, possibly contributing to reproductive barriers between closely related species. Here, we studied the diversification of tail fork depth through time in hirundines to infer its function, which remains unclear due to the competing two alternative hypotheses: the sexual selection hypothesis, which is a classic explanation of deeply forked tails, proposed that this trait has evolved via sexual selection, which was then challenged by the viability selection hypothesis, which proposed that deeply forked tails have mainly evolved via viability selection for enhancing aerodynamic performance during aerial foraging on large prey. We found a late burst of tail fork depth, but not of bill length, i.e., an index of prey size. The observed pattern is consistent with the sexual selection hypothesis but not with the viability selection hypothesis.

A central mechanism of sexual selection theory is Fisher's process, which refers to the coevolution of male traits and female preferences, in which preference is indirectly selected through genetic association with male trait alleles built up via mate choice. However, empirical studies often fail to detect strong trait-preference genetic correlations, raising doubts about the importance of Fisherian selection in nature. Notably, the theoretical expectation that genetic correlations are essential for trait-preference coevolution through Fisherian selection derives largely from models assuming infinitely large populations, whereas real populations are finite. Using population genetic models, I show that interactions between Fisherian selection and genetic drift can fundamentally decouple trait-preference genetic correlations from the evolution of male traits and female preferences. Genetic drift generally reduces expected trait-preference correlations but simultaneously promotes the expected increase in female preference frequency beyond deterministic predictions. Consequently, in populations of realistic sizes, trait-preference correlations may often be weak or even negative, particularly when recombination among trait and preference loci is infrequent, but substantial trait-preference coevolution can still occur. Therefore, the strength of genetic correlations may be an unreliable indicator of the extent of trait and preference coevolution, offering a potential resolution to a longstanding dilemma in sexual selection theory.

Sexual reproduction is widespread despite being less efficient than asexual reproduction. While its long-term evolutionary benefits are well recognized, it remains unclear why facultative sex, which should allow lineages to balance the advantages of both sexual and asexual reproduction, is not more common. One potential reason is that intermittent sex imposes novel costs compared to obligate sex, limiting the persistence of facultatively sexual lineages and constraining introgression. We test this possibility using the sexually polymorphic aphid parasitoid wasp Lysiphlebus fabarum. We reared offspring from females who reproduced asexually or by facultative sex for three generations (without sex after the founding generation). We genotyped F1 females to confirm facultative sex and used antennomere number, a phenotypic marker associated with reproductive mode, to test whether mixed sexual-asexual genotypes could be tracked across generations. We found multiple barriers to facultative sex. Mating did not always result in offspring with sexual-asexual genotypes, and when sex did occur, broods were usually comprised of asexually and sexually produced offspring. Additionally, lineages founded by females produced through facultative sex showed reduced fecundity compared to asexually produced broods. We saw declining frequencies of the sexual antenna phenotype in the generations after facultative sex, suggesting that genotypes generated by facultative sex are selected against. Overall, our results provide empirical support for the idea that facultative sex can impose costs that persist beyond the initial sexual event. These costs, together with low realised rates of sex, may limit long-term introgression and explain why facultative sex appears rare compared to obligate sex.

The size of an epidemic can influence the strength of selection acting on hosts and parasites, but whether epidemic size consistently shapes host-parasite (co)-evolution remains unclear. I conducted a meta-analysis of studies that simultaneously quantified epidemic size and evolutionary change in hosts, parasites or their interactions, synthesising 123 effect sizes from 11 studies. I tested whether epidemic size was associated with four components of evolutionary change: host evolution, parasite evolution, non-additive host-parasite coevolution and net coevolution. Larger epidemics were associated with greater host evolutionary change in invertebrates, whereas the relationship was positive in plants and negative but non-significant in bacteria. Parasite evolution, non-additive coevolution and net coevolution were not detectably associated with epidemic size, although parasite infectivity showed a relatively consistent increase across studies. These results provide limited evidence for a general relationship between epidemic size and host-parasite (co)-evolution and instead suggest that evolutionary responses depend on the host-parasite system and broader ecological and temporal context. Interpretation is constrained by the small and taxonomically biased evidence base, particularly the strong representation of Daphnia, and by substantial heterogeneity in how epidemic size and evolutionary change were measured and defined. More studies across diverse host-parasite systems are required that track both evolutionary change and disease prevalence through time. This work also provides an empirical basis for incorporating coevolutionary feedbacks into quantitative epidemiological models.